Heirloom Seeds: Why they are valuable & timeless

Disclaimer: This post contains some affiliate links. The small commission we receive if you choose to purchase goes towards making this gardening education available for free! We do not affiliate for anything we do not personally use.

Looking to buy heirloom seeds? Scroll all the way to the bottom.

Thanks so much for your support!

Why heirloom seeds?

One of the most important goals in sustainable gardening is saving seeds from some of our valued plants and using them to grow the next cycle of plants the following year. 

Humanity has observed this cycle in nature for countless generations and learned to harvest and save seeds from the most useful plants encountered. 

Seeds of favored varieties were treasured and stored carefully and passed as heirlooms from mother to daughter and father to son. 

Heirloom seeds represent not only the blueprints and potential to produce interesting plants but also, through careful record-keeping, store the history of the people and cultures who preserved and cultivated them.  


What is an heirloom seed?

It can be confusing shopping for seeds; we see in the stores non-GMO, organic, heirloom, etc. 

What do these all mean and what exactly is an heirloom vegetable? 

Seeds are categorized by how the parent plants were propagated. 

Open-pollinated seeds are those that, if isolated from other varieties, will produce children that are very close to the parents in terms of properties.  Usually a seed has to be stable for at least seven generations to be considered an open pollinated variety. 

Heirloom seeds are open-pollinated varieties that have an extensive history detailing how they were saved or originally bred.  

Opposite that are hybrid varieties that won't produce seeds that are "true-to-type", meaning that their children will likely be different from the parent. Hybrid plants don't produce seeds that are worth saving because they are likely to have unstable properties.  

Hybrids are grown for their disease resistance and vigor, but in order to produce a consistent supply of hybrid seeds, the seed provider will need to have stocks of the parent plants to produce the hybrids.

You may have seen seeds labeled F1 or F2 in the stores and wondered what that meant.  This refers to the "filial" generation from the stable parent variety, so F2 means that the hybrid is 2 generations removed from the stable parents that were used to crossbreed it. 

This site explains how it's not worth saving F1 seed.

Hybrids differ from genetically-engineered seeds (GM) since they are usually produced using traditional cross-breeding instead of gene-editing techniques.

America diversifies its diet

When the first European colonists landed on the shores of eastern America all the way up to the middle of the 19th century, the diets of most Americans were focused on subsistence instead of the wide variety of fruits and vegetables that we take for granted today. 

It was at this point, with a large influx of new immigrants, new agricultural technology, and an oversupply of basic foodstuffs like corn and wheat, that America started diversifying their diets beyond subsistence. 

A really fascinating book about the time period is "Food Explorer", which delves into the biography of David Fairchild, a botanist who was responsible for introducing America to avocados, dates, quinoa, kale and many other foods that he and his fellow colleagues at the Department of Plant Introduction found in their travels around the world.

This was the golden age of seed catalogs, with gardeners around America inspired by the potential of growing all kinds of interesting flowers and vegetables from around the world.

Even as a kid in the 80s, I remember drooling over a Burpee catalog and imagining the amazing things I could grow from the fanciful descriptions.  The difference between the late nineteenth century and today is the huge drop in diversity in plant varieties that we grow.  

There has been over a 90% drop in the number of seed varieties that are still available on the market compared to the end of the 19th century.  In our modern "monoculture" agricultural system, most farmers plant the same top plant varieties.  The problem occurs when a new bacteria, fungus, or virus targets a trait in those top performing varieties that quickly decimates the global supply and production of that plant.

The best way to combat this inherent weakness in our modern agricultural system is to save seeds from a diverse background.

A Return To Seed Saving

I feel that the best reason for learning and cultivating heirloom seeds goes back to the meaning of the word heirloom, which means something valuable passed down from earlier generations.  Heirloom seeds are valuable items cultivated by our parents and grandparents (increasingly our great and great-great grandparents), and the stories of how they were kept and preserved are deeply compelling.

In 1975, Ken and Diane Ott Whealy started a seed exchange using a tomato and morning glory variety brought to America by Diane's Bavarian immigrant great-grandparents. 

Building on their initial mission to save seeds with interesting cultural history that they found were becoming unavailable in seed catalogs, this exchange has grown into Seed Savers Exchange, a national non-profit with 13,000 members. 

It maintains one of the largest seed banks in America, with over 20,000 varieties of seeds, a 850 acre farm in Iowa and has deposited over 3000 varieties in the Svalbard Global Seed Vault in Norway. 

About 20% of these varieties have "stories", recalling where the seed came from and why it was preserved.  Many of these seeds are not tastier or significantly more productive than commercial varieties, but they were usually grown because they had a unique trait that differentiated them and prompted their preservation.  Quite often, I find the story about the varieties more interesting than the horticultural potential of the seed, with many of the stories painting a picture of the various ethnic groups that immigrated to different parts of America.  


Moving towards a Diverse Future

Although it's important to preserve our seed heritage and reclaim seed varieties that are on the brink of extinction, the best hope for our seed future is continuing the work of plant breeding, which involves stabilizing hybrid varieties that show promise and creatively breeding plants to produce new open-pollinated varieties.  

Unfortunately, overzealous plant protection legislation serving the interest of large corporations has turned the commercial seed business into big business.  As these corporations have become more involved in plant breeding, they recruit the best talent from universities and direct their research into producing plant varieties that improve the bottom line of the corporation. 

Almost always, these desired plant properties do not include taste or more importantly, viability in small backyard gardens.  The fallout from this is that we as gardeners have less seed varieties to choose from because there are less plant breeders doing their work.

A initiative called the Open Source Seed Initiative (osseeds.org) started in 2014 to reclaim seed varieties for experimentation by plant breeders and farmers. 

It borrows heavily from the successful open source movement in the software industry where the results of seed experimentation are freely offered to the public domain as long as nobody ever tries to patent or restrict usage in the future.  Here is a list of plant breeders (with some short bios) agreeing to be a part of this initiative

A surprisingly large number of them are formally trained biologists who bucked the current agricultural academic environment (which is dominated by private investment in public research) to contribute to the public good through their plant breeding work.


Aside from annual plant breeder work, there are also researchers that are interested in restoring historical "landrace" varieties of wheat, rice and other cereal grains that were historically grown in local communities during the 19th century.  This work is interesting because they turn traditional agricultural concepts on their head, such as dryland rice and perennial wheat varieties.  In addition, some of these older varieties of wheat, like Einkorn and Emmer, are better tolerated by people suffering gluten sensitivies since they haven't been overselected like much of modern wheat varieties.

The Choice is Yours

I recommend that when you are planning out your seed purchases you not only consider the types of plants you want to grow but also the traits in those plants that are important to you. 

Is taste important, or have you had a lot of trouble growing a desired crop and it's more important that you get some disease resistance?  Are you growing your crops to maximize your health or improve your nutrition?  You might want to consider different colors of your favorite veggies to grow, since they might have more anthocyanins or lycopenes. 

Being more informed about the history and source of your seeds will strengthen your connection to your plants and may even inspire you to save the seeds from your top varieties for the following year.  You'll renew your connection to nature and start to become more in tune with the seasonal and plant cycles that sustain us.


Comments 11

  1. This is beautiful and amazing! I hope to be able to grow and collect seeds to use year after year!

  2. Post
    1. Post
  3. My mom taught me to save my seeds year after year. Am I glad she did! I have been saving my favorite seeds for over 40 years now. Even my granddaughter finds me the seeds of the tomatoes that she loves. Thanks for a great article!

    1. Post
  4. I am an urban farmer living at my farm 61 kms from Central Mumbai,India. Interested in exploring to understand more about Heirloom seeds which may be native to my country’s diversity in most climatic, geographic, social and lifestyle behaviour patterns. If this interests you do respond to start a digital dialogue. Best wishes. Jai Hind.

    1. Post
  5. I found this site looking for seeds that would produce more. Very interesting. I need to learn more. 20 years ago I had some potatoes from the grocery store sprouted, so I planted some. I grew beautiful plants that gave me a handful of dime sized potatoes. My 1st lesson with GMO garbage.

    1. Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *